pruning broken branch

Pruning a broken branch

Updated: June 25, 2021

Pruning, or the selective removal of specific branches or stems, is an important maintenance practice that helps to keep your trees healthy for many years to come.

Important reasons to prune mature trees include controlling size, providing clearance for foot traffic or vehicles, removing potentially hazardous branches, and improving appearance.

  • Pruning large trees and any tree work that requires climbing or near power lines is dangerous and should be performed by a licensed tree expert or certified arborist.
  • Remove damaged, diseased, and dead branches at any time. 
reasons for pruning illustration
Illustration of Reasons to Prune Trees (red branches are to be removed)
Credit: Don Wittig, former UME Master Gardener

Why prune young trees?

Young trees can be pruned to prevent future branch structure issues or, if needed, to create a desired shape or form.

Young trees frequently need pruning to establish a beneficial branch structure. At first, however, newly planted trees should be pruned only when there are broken or damaged branches. It is a myth that trees should be pruned when planted to compensate for root loss, because leaves and shoot tips provide food and growth substances that stimulate root production.

Young trees need their low temporary branches to provide sustenance, though they should be kept short enough not to compete with permanent branches. Low temporary branches also protect the trunk. As the tree grows taller, the lower branches may be removed, keeping desirable branches. As a tree grows, branches do not move farther off the ground. Prune off the low temporary branches gradually, over a course of several years, and before they reach one inch in diameter.

Never remove more than one-fourth of a tree’s branches at one time. Remember: it is better to make several small pruning cuts than one big cut. Avoid cutting large branches when possible.

Dominant leader

Maintain a single dominant leader stem, which is the tallest, strongest, main branch of the tree. Do not prune back this leader or allow secondary branches to outgrow the leader. If a tree has co-dominant stems (known as double leaders), remove one to avoid structural weakness. Save the straightest and strongest stem. Prevent competing branches from growing larger than half the trunk diameter by removing them or bending them downward to slow their growth.

Branch structure

Proper pruning leaves secondary branches all along the larger branches. It is better to remove branches from the edges of the tree.

Branch attachment or crotches

The angle formed between two branches is called the crotch. Sometimes branches develop with narrow angles of attachment, that is, with tight crotches. As the tree grows, the bark becomes enclosed within the crotch, which leads to weakness and branch failure or dieback. Branches with narrow crotches should be removed or stretched to a wider angle when the tree is young. To widen crotches, use spacers, sometimes called spreaders, or simply bend the branch to a wider angle while it is still young and supple. Spreaders can be made of wire or wood and are positioned in a crotch, pushing it wider. Weights, also, can be tied to branches to widen the crotch angle. The spreaders or weights should be removed after a season. The spreading and spacing of branches is an old established practice for fruit trees that can be applied to any tree.

pruning crotches
Weak crotch (left) and strong crotch (right). V-shaped crotches are weaker than U-shaped
crotches.

Resource

Pruning techniques for mature trees

poorly pruned mature tree
Poorly pruned and improperly mulched tree

If properly pruned when young, mature trees seldom need major pruning. These three techniques illustrated below can be used by tree experts when necessary. Tree work that requires climbing or near overhead power lines should be performed by a trained tree-care professional. 

Crown thinning

crown thinning
Crown thinning. Green branches are to be removed.

The selective removal of branches to increase light penetration and air movement in the crown, or canopy, of a tree.

Thinning reduces wind damage by diminishing the degree of wind block. No more than one-fourth of the living crown should be removed at any one time. Removing a portion of a branch causes the terminal portion of the remaining branch to become dominant. This remaining dominant branch should be strongly attached. Therefore, when thinning it is best to cut to a side branch that is at least one-third the size of the one being cut. Branches smaller than that will not be joined as strongly and be more susceptible to breakage. When cutting back a branch to one of its lateral branches, remove no more than one-fourth of its foliage.

Crown raising

crown raising
Crown raising. Green branches are to be removed.

The removal of lower branches.

Afterward, at least two-thirds of the total height of the tree must still have living branches. Crown raising is frequently done to allow foot or vehicle traffic or lawnmowers under the tree. Street trees require at least 16 feet of clearance for trucks. Lawn trees need eight feet of clearance for foot traffic. Trees used for screening or windbreak can be allowed to have branches near the ground.

Crown reduction

crown reduction
Crown reduction. Green branches are to be removed.

The proper removal of upper branches when the tree has become too tall.

When a tree is too tall, it is better to remove it. Never top (removing large branches or/and trunks from treetops, leaving stubs, and not making proper pruning cuts) a shade tree to control its size. Topping causes the growth of many weak suckers that may break off when they become heavy branches causing a possibly hazardous situation. Wood rots are more likely to be a problem in topped trees. If a tree must be reduced in size, use the crown reduction pruning entire branches at their point of origin.
Tipping is the procedure of cutting lateral branches between nodes or buds to reduce crown width rather than cutting back to a node or crotch. It is another procedure that should not be used.

Proper pruning cuts

branch collar
The branch collar is usually visible and is the area of swollen tissue that forms around the base of a branch where it is attached to 
the tree.  

Never cut the branch flush with the trunk, thus removing the branch collar. The collar is an area of natural shedding that contains chemically protective tissue that encourages rapid sealing off of the wound left behind after pruning.

Tree wound dressing, paint, or shellac should not be applied over the cut surfaces.  Research shows that dressings can shelter disease organisms and slow the wound-healing process (compartmentalization).

Removing larger branches

Removing branches over 1½ inches in diameter requires a special three-cut pruning process (see illustration below). This avoids the misfortunate event when, before the pruning cut is even complete, the weight of the branch breaks it off, leaving a ragged wound and ripping bark from the trunk.

  1. Saw an upward cut halfway through the branch about a foot beyond where it intersects the trunk.
  2. Then saw a cut downward all the way through the branch somewhat farther out from the first undercut. This removes the excess weight of the branch.
  3. Now make the third and finishing cut perpendicular to the trunk on the branch side of the collar which is the thickened area at the intersection of the branches. (If there is no visible collar, make the final cut where the top of the branch makes an abrupt turn from the trunk.) 
location of pruning cuts

Pruning conifers

Plant larger conifers such as fir, spruce, and pine only in areas where heavy pruning will not be necessary, since new shoots will not develop from cuts made in the older wood.  Conifers do not need pruning for spacing of lateral branches. Branches emerge close to each other but will not crowd out each other or the leader. Appropriate vertical spacing occurs naturally.

Firs and spruces may only be lightly pruned in late summer, fall, or winter after growth is completed. Leave the side buds present along the twigs. Never cut the central leader. 

Pines may be lightly pruned in early June to increase density by removing the bud plus an inch or so of the young shoots. If large cuts are made, new branches will arise only in the area where needles are present along the stem. To thicken the growth of conifer trees such as pine, fir, or spruce pinch out half the candle, which is the new spring growth, when it is about two inches long. Use fingers rather than shears.  (refer to the illustration below)

pine candle pinching
Pine candle pinching

When to prune

  • The following trees develop flowers on old wood; therefore, prune them immediately after they are finished blooming. Serviceberry (Amelanchier), redbud (Cercis), fringe tree (Chionanthus), dogwood (Cornus), saucer magnolia (Magnolia soulangiana), crabapple (Malus), and flowering cherries (Prunus). 
  • These trees flower in summer or autumn on new wood; therefore, prune them during the late winter or spring while they are dormant. Smoke tree (Cotinus coggygria), American holly (Ilex opaca), and crape myrtle (Lagerstroemia indica). 
  • Stressed trees should not be pruned since all leaves are important for recovery. However, diseased, broken, or dead branches should be removed.
  • Some trees, including birch, maple, dogwood, elm, walnut, and yellowwood exude an excessive amount of sap (referred to as bleeding) from pruning wounds made in late winter or early spring. This is not harmful to the tree, however, it can be avoided by pruning such trees in late fall/early winter (November-December) or after new spring growth is finished in May or June. 

Tree tips

  • Physical damage to tree trunks requires special attention. All loose bark from the edges of a wound should be trimmed back to bark firmly attached to the sapwood (the layer of wood under the bark). Carefully remove all shredded sapwood, too, and leave a smooth surface.
  • Leave old wounds undisturbed, especially when callus or tissue has developed along the outside edge of the wound. Trees protect themselves from decay organisms through a process called compartmentalization, and callus tissue is part of that defense mechanism.
  • Broken terminal leaders can be replaced by tying a lateral branch into a vertical position braced with a wooden stick, making it the new leader. When the new leader is growing vertically on its own, remove the tie.
leader replacement
When the leader dies or is broken, a new one can be established by fastening the next lower branch into a vertical position.

Videos

YouTube playlist for pruning trees and shrubs

Based on Home and Garden Information Center publication HG 84 Pruning Ornamental Plants, author Virginia Williams, CPH, Former Home and Garden Information Center Consultant, UME Bulletin 150 Pruning Ornamental Trees and Shrubs, author Dr. Francis Gouin (deceased) and revised by Ray Bosmans, Professor Emeritus, University of Maryland Extension, and the Maryland Master Gardener Handbook (revised January 2012).

Bedker, Peter; O'Brien, Joseph; Mielke, Manfred. 2012. How to Prune Trees. NA-FR-01-95 [Revised August 2012]. USDA, Forest Service, State, and Private Forestry, Northeastern Area, 11 Campus Blvd., Ste 200 Newtown Square, PA 19073

Compiled by Debra Ricigliano, Home and Garden Information Center, June 2019.

Additional resources

A Guide to Successful Pruning: Deciduous Tree Pruning Calendar | Virginia Cooperative Extension

How to Prune Trees | USDA Forest Service